The Allegation Emerges
Dave Portnoy, founder of Barstool Sports, made a significant public claim in 2020 regarding the co-hosts of the popular podcast ‘Call Her Daddy.’ Portnoy alleged that Alexandra Cooper and Sofia Franklyn had planned to accuse Barstool Sports of sexual harassment. This purported strategy was, according to Portnoy, designed to enable their departure from the company.
The accusation surfaced during a period of intense contractual disagreement. The podcast, which had gained substantial traction since its launch, found itself at the center of a public business dispute. This dispute involved not only the hosts and Barstool Sports but also external management.
The ‘Call Her Daddy’ Phenomenon
‘Call Her Daddy’ launched in 2018, quickly gaining a substantial following. The podcast, hosted by Alexandra Cooper and Sofia Franklyn, focused on candid discussions about sex, relationships, and daily life. Its raw and unfiltered approach resonated with a young audience, particularly women.
Barstool Sports, known for its irreverent and often controversial content, provided the platform for the podcast’s initial growth. The show rapidly became one of Barstool’s most successful intellectual properties. It generated significant revenue through advertising, merchandise sales, and subscriptions.
Early Success and Contractual Structures
The podcast’s immediate success led to increased scrutiny of its financial arrangements. Cooper and Franklyn, as content creators, operated under contracts with Barstool Sports. These agreements typically outline revenue splits, intellectual property ownership, and duration of service.
The exact terms of their initial contracts were not publicly disclosed. However, the rapid escalation of their popularity created leverage for renegotiation. This leverage became a central factor in the subsequent dispute.
The 2020 Contract Dispute
In early 2020, reports surfaced of a major rift between Cooper, Franklyn, and Barstool Sports. The co-hosts reportedly sought new terms for their contracts, including higher salaries and greater control over the podcast’s intellectual property. Negotiations stalled, leading to a temporary hiatus in new episodes.
This period of silence fueled speculation among listeners and the media. The hosts’ absence from the airwaves suggested a significant internal conflict. Barstool Sports, accustomed to public disputes, found itself in a high-profile standoff with two of its most valuable talents.
Portnoy’s Public Intervention
Dave Portnoy, known for his direct and often confrontational communication style, addressed the situation publicly. He released a podcast episode titled ‘Daddy Speaks’ on May 17, 2020. In this episode, Portnoy detailed Barstool’s perspective on the dispute.
Portnoy outlined the financial offers made to Cooper and Franklyn. He stated that Barstool had offered each host a base salary of $500,000, along with bonuses and intellectual property rights. He characterized these offers as generous, given the existing contractual obligations.
The Sexual Harassment Allegation Claim
It was during the ‘Daddy Speaks’ episode that Portnoy made the specific claim about the sexual harassment accusations. He stated that he had been informed of a plan by Cooper and Franklyn to allege sexual harassment against Barstool Sports. This tactic, he claimed, was intended to nullify their contracts and allow them to depart without legal repercussions.
Portnoy did not specify the nature of the alleged harassment or the individuals involved. He presented the claim as a strategy employed by the hosts’ new management. This management team reportedly advised Cooper and Franklyn during their contract renegotiations.
Reactions to the Claim
The allegation by Portnoy generated immediate and widespread discussion. It added a serious dimension to what was already a high-stakes business negotiation. The claim cast a shadow over the motivations of the ‘Call Her Daddy’ co-hosts.
Neither Alexandra Cooper nor Sofia Franklyn publicly confirmed or denied Portnoy’s specific claim about planning sexual harassment accusations. Their public statements at the time focused on issues of creative control, financial compensation, and their desire for a fair deal.
“I knew that I was going to lose money but I knew that I had to do what was right for myself and for my future,” Sofia Franklyn stated in a 2020 Instagram video, referencing her decision to leave.
The Resolution and Aftermath
The dispute ultimately led to a split between the ‘Call Her Daddy’ co-hosts. Sofia Franklyn departed from the podcast and Barstool Sports. She subsequently launched her own podcast, ‘Sofia with an F,’ in 2020.
Alexandra Cooper remained with Barstool Sports. She signed a new deal in 2020, taking over as the sole host of ‘Call Her Daddy.’ The podcast continued its success under her leadership, maintaining its strong listenership.
Cooper’s New Ventures
In 2021, Alexandra Cooper signed an exclusive deal with Spotify for ‘Call Her Daddy.’ The reported value of this deal was $60 million over three years. This move further solidified her position as a prominent figure in the podcasting industry. The Spotify deal marked a significant milestone for both Cooper and the podcast.
The transition demonstrated the immense value of intellectual property in the digital content landscape. It also highlighted the evolving relationship between creators and media companies.
The Broader Implications
The ‘Call Her Daddy’ saga, including Portnoy’s sexual harassment claim, offered insights into modern media contracts. It showcased the complexities of talent retention, intellectual property rights, and revenue sharing in the podcasting world. The public nature of the dispute meant that many of these issues were debated openly.
The incident also touched upon the serious implications of sexual harassment allegations. Such claims, whether made or merely alleged to be planned, carry significant weight. They can impact reputations, legal proceedings, and company valuations.
Transparency in Content Creation
The events of 2020 prompted discussions about transparency between content creators and their parent companies. The ‘Call Her Daddy’ situation became a case study in how quickly successful digital ventures can lead to high-stakes conflicts. It emphasized the importance of clear contractual terms and open communication.
The entertainment industry continues to grapple with these issues. The rise of independent creators and the power of direct-to-consumer platforms contribute to a constantly shifting landscape. Barstool Sports, Dave Portnoy, Alexandra Cooper, and Sofia Franklyn all navigated this landscape, leaving a notable mark.
Companies negotiate. Creators demand. Audiences watch.
Barstool.









